Article updated April 2024
Lorna Jane vindicated after two-year, $570,000 bullying case: Lessons for your social media policy
Legal experts are urging businesses to train their staff in up-to-date social media policies after activewear brand Lorna Jane won a two-year legal battle in November against a former employee who claimed the company was responsible for the psychiatric impacts of bullying at work.
Former Brisbane store manager Amy Robinson filed a legal claim against Lorna Jane in 2015, seeking $570,000 in damages. The former manager claimed Lorna Jane was negligent and should be held responsible for her being bullied by a Learning and Development Manager at the company, which led to psychiatric illness and a loss of employment and future employability.
Addressing bullying in your social media policy
The company came out swinging against the claims early on, posting a later-deleted Facebook post in 2015 defending itself against the claims and saying it had been “very disappointed” by what had been reported in the media about the case.
The claims included that Robinson was bullied and called a variety of names while working at the company over a period of 20 weeks. Robinson also put forward two Facebook posts made by the Learning and Development Manager, which she believed were critical of her.
One of these involved the manager writing a status on Facebook saying: “What a day! It’s difficult to soar with the eagles when your [sic] surrounded by turkeys. Is it too late to pursue a different career?”
In deciding the case in November 2016, Queensland District Court Judge Gregory Koppenol found Robinson “failed to prove each aspect of her claim”, which he subsequently dismissed.
He found the Facebook posts had indeed been made by the manager, but that Lorna Jane should not be held liable for these for a range of reasons, including that the Learning and Development Manager thought they were only visible on her personal Facebook page.
However, it was the process the company went through once being made aware of the posts that led to the judge finding the company had taken the right action.
“Once Lorna Jane became aware of the Facebook posts, [the manager] was immediately instructed to take them down (delete them), which she did. Lorna Jane also immediately (a) took disciplinary action against [her], (b) removed the DFO store from [her] control, and (c) arranged for Ms Robinson to report to [another staff member] and not to [the manager].
In my view, those were the appropriate steps to take in response to Lorna Jane’s becoming aware of the offending Facebook posts,” Judge Koppenol said in the decision.
Social Media Policy and Subsequent Action is Key
While the court’s decision also examined a number of other claims made by Robinson, including concerning physical and psychiatric injuries, Director of Workplace Law Shane Koelmeyer says businesses can learn a lot from this case when reviewing their social media policies for the future.
Koelmeyer says it was Lorna Jane’s actions in relation to its social media policy that convinced the court it was not liable for the Facebook posts in question.
“Lorna Jane had strict policies in place, and once they became aware of it [posts that could have breached the policy], the worker was immediately instructed to delete them,” Koelmeyer says.
Koelmeyer says small businesses can learn from the swift way Lorna Jane acted when it became aware of the Facebook posts, reflecting that if all staff are regularly trained about a company’s codes of conduct, it makes it much easier to enforce these the minute that concerns arise.
Social media platforms are always changing, so it’s critical companies regularly review whether their policies fit with how workers use social media.
“What is and isn’t acceptable is ever-changing in society, so it is important to keep reminding and training your staff,” he says.
Koelmeyer believes Lorna Jane was able to win the case because it could demonstrate clear action once a complaint had been made about a staff member’s social media use.
“Make sure that when it’s brought to your attention, you then act appropriately,” he says.
This article was originally posted on SmartCompany.com.au by Emma Koehn on Wednesday 10th January 2018.
Some related article you may be interested in:
Using the Evolt 360 Body Scanner to Get Members Through The Door
Are you looking for ways to get members to reconnect with you and motivate them to get back into their workout routines? The cost of living crisis is being felt across Australia, and gyms need to offer increased value to members for those membership fees to be justified in the next round of household spending
8 Productivity Tips For Procrastinators
As a solo business operator, procrastination can be extremely detrimental. We recently asked a sample of business owners to share their tips to keep it at bay. Here are the top things we identified that help them to be freakishly productive. Enjoy these 8 productivity tips for procrastinators: Productivity tip: Keep the home office tidy
Solutions For Filling Up Empty Cycle Studios
With the home gym equipment market offering increasingly great value, and the humble stationary bike now more interactive and connected than ever before, you may be noticing less bums on seats in your cycle studio. A cardio theatre is a significant investment, both with the purchase and maintenance of exercise equipment and also due to
MZ-Open: Integrating MyZone With Your Existing Smart Watch
From 13th March 2024, Myzone will be switching on its newest feature, MZ-Open – an access function, which enables members to integrate their existing smart watch with the Myzone ecosystem at their gym. This function means gym owners can create more community within their membership, offering more incentives for their members to stick around, get
Wello Works: Bringing Balance to Coworking Spaces Through Wellness
The popularity of coworking spaces has been trending upward for several years now. The same people who embraced the flexibility of working remotely in a post-pandemic world, are increasingly craving the social and productivity benefits that come with separating the work environment from the home. Fitness and wellness entrepreneur, Tony de Leede, has created a
Picking the Perfect Playlist For Your Gym: Here’s What the Research Says
People like to feel pumped up and energised when working out. How do you motivate yourself and get the results you want? One way is to crank up the music and jam to your favourite songs. Did you know there’s actually some research to support why picking the perfect playlist for your gym is important?